In a stress-strain curve generated throughout a tensile test, the steep in the linear section at the beginning is where Young’s Modulus is determined. Where it very first deviates from linearity is the yield strength." href="">

Figure 1 In a stress-strain curve generated during a tensile test, the steep in the linear section at the start is wherein Young’s Modulus is determined. Whereby it first deviates native linearity is the productivity strength.

You are watching: A material as hard as steel is not elastic.

The terms strength and also stiffness frequently are provided interchangeably, yet they have various meanings and significance.


Strength is a measure up of the tension that can be applied to a material prior to it permanently deforms (yield strength) or breaks (tensile strength). If the used stress is less than the productivity strength, the product returns come its initial shape as soon as the stress is removed. If the used stress above the yield strength, plastic or long-term deformation occurs, and also the material deserve to no much longer return to its initial shape as soon as the pack is removed.

Keep in mind the this long-term deformation is the score in stamping. The initial shape is the level sheet metal, and also formed components need to retain their form permanently. If the chosen sheet steel cannot be developed into the desired shape under the selected handling conditions, the applied stresses are greater than the tensile strength of the sheet metal, which causes cracks to kind in the part.

A material’s toughness is a function its chemical composition, the thermo-mechanical handling route (such as converting from a special slab come a thin sheet), and subsequent warmth treatments. These variables make it impossible to state the one product is constantly stronger than another. Because that example, numerous aluminum qualities are stronger than steel grades, however rarely room they intended because that the same application.


Stiffness relates to just how a component bends under pack while still returning to its initial shape once the load is removed. Since the ingredient dimensions space unchanged after load is removed, stiffness is connected with elastic deformation.

At one extreme, a rubber band is an instance of a material with short stiffness—it have the right to withstand a lot of deformation and also still return to its original dimensions once the load is removed. Top top the various other hand, a high-stiffness product like diamond will elastically deform only a little amount when pack is applied.

Stiffness that a component is a role of both material and also geometry. On the product side, stiffness depends on the modulus of elasticity, likewise known as Young’s Modulus and abbreviated together E. Young’s Modulus is the ratio of anxiety to stress, overload at very small strains. In a stress-strain curve generated throughout a tensile test, the steep in the linear section at the start is wherein the modulus is determined. Whereby it first deviates indigenous linearity is the yield strength (see Figure 1).

Unlike strength, which deserve to vary from grade to grade or even coil to coil, Young’s Modulus is constant for a provided metal and also is elevation of warmth treatment, processing, or cold work. Young’s Modulus for stole (29 million PSI) is three times that of aluminum (10 million PSI). This means that because that a solved geometry, a component made out of steel will be 3 times together stiff as if it to be made the end of aluminum. In various other words, one aluminum component under pack will deflect three times as lot as a likewise loaded stole part.

The thickness and shape of the formed part also contributes to its stiffness. Stiffness is proportional to the cube of the thickness. Come neutralize aluminum being one-third the stiffness the steel, one aluminum component must it is in made 44 percent thicker 보다 the steel part. Even with this increased thickness, over there is a potential for load savings due to the fact that aluminum is one-third the thickness of steel.

Having much more shape in the part also rises stiffness. A piece of record is flimsy, yet putting a crease under the facility of it provides it much more rigid. Darts, beads, and ribs are shapes that can be included to parts to restrict flexing. Top top surface parts visible to the consumer, lock are dubbed feature currently or personality lines, emphasize for their aesthetic benefits.


For instance, the panels that comprise a pickup van bed (see Figure 2) are several of the flattest on the truck. However there isn’t a truck on the industry that is designed without this ribs to help increase overall stiffness.

However, the sheet steel needs come be saturated formable come accommodate the extr shapes. The ribs in the van bed panel might not be an extremely deep, however the metal needs to be extended over brief distances. A higher-tonnage stamping press also is necessary to generate the compelled forces over the whole panel.

Aluminum Versus steel in Automobiles

For skin panels such together hoods, doors, and liftgates, automakers choose to use a sheet metal with as high a strength as feasible so that the dashboard has enough dent resistance. Thickness affect dent resistance together well, limiting the degree to which panel thickness deserve to be decreased to decrease weight.

Stiffness constraints further limit just how thin the skin panels have the right to be. If the panels room too thin, they can start to wave and flutter together the auto travels under the road—unless personality lines are placed in because that extra style.

Although it might sound obvious, automakers likewise need come specify a sheet steel product that have the right to be produced to class A surface standards. Current modern technology limits this to sheet stole or aluminum through strength less than 45,000 PSI. Joining is no a far-ranging hurdle, because several cost-effective techniques are easily accessible to friend the outer panel come the within panel.

With a similar upper strength available in either material, and also several grades from several carriers of either steel that can be produced sufficiently thin, the one providing the best mix of cost and weight save will arise as the optimum choice for hang-on panel applications.

Body structure applications current different challenges. Stiffness is crucial for handling and also noise, vibration, and harshness (NVH). In addition to the innate stiffness linked with the part’s material and geometry, NVH qualities can be boosted with lightweight polymer foams. Crash resistance, on the various other hand, is more closely associated with strength. For the exact same design, steel has actually a far-reaching advantage in accessible choices. If a course A surface ar is no required, steel grades are obtainable commercially through tensile strength exceeding 230,000 PSI.

This no to say the aluminum human body structures room not possible. There are numerous examples ~ above the market, although castle skew toward much more expensive vehicles in which lightweighting for fuel economy improvements is no a primary issue and also the sheet metal expense is a smaller portion of the transaction price.

Improved crash performance will certainly come with greater strength, as well as components that have crash-resistant designs, such as closed sections, larger flanges, or more shape—all the which can require greater formability indigenous the higher-strength aluminum grades.

Furthermore, this parts should be joined in a robust, high-speed, cost-effective manner. Ford spent nearly $1 exchange rate to rebuild the F150 tree to stamp and assemble the aluminum-intensive cab and bed and also join it to a stole frame. This financial hurdle might limit the variety of automakers ready to walk all-in and make an aluminum-intensive human body structure.

See more: What Does 20/25 V Is 20/25 Vision Good, What Does It Mean

Daniel J. Schaeffler is president of engineering Quality services Inc., P.O. Box 187, Southfield, MI 48037, 248-667-8335, sales,, and also chief content officer v 4M partner LLC, P.O. Box 71191, Rochester Hills, MI 48307,