In the accept letter take care of Potter obtained from Hogwarts, the second page has actually a list of requirements for the begin of school. In ~ the bottom of the letter it states:

PARENTS are REMINDED THAT very first YEARS are NOT permitted THEIR very own BROOMSTICK

And yet, very early top top in his very first year, harry Potter is gifted a Nimbus 2000 by the head the his home Professor McGonagall. This no doubt do Harry Potter the only very first year college student to be enabled their own broom.

Seems to me the McGonagall was deliberately breaking the rules to advantage her very own house, which appears unethical.


*

In Sorcerer"s Stone, that is defined that unique provisions to be made to permit Harry to have a broomstick.

You are watching: Who gave harry the nimbus 2000

"Potter"s been sent out a broomstick, Professor," stated Malfoy quickly.

"Yes, yes, that"s right," claimed Professor Flitwick, beaming in ~ Harry. "Professor McGonagall told me all around the unique circumstances, Potter. And what design is it?"

"A Nimbus two Thousand, sir."

Sorcerer"s Stone - web page 165 - united state Hardcover


*

*

As Kevin noted, harry was provided a one-of-a-kind exemption. From book 1:

"He"s simply the construct for a Seeker, too," claimed Wood, now walking around Harry and also staring at him. "Light -- speedy -- we"ll have to acquire him a kind broom, Professor -- a Nimbus two Thousand or a Cleansweep Seven, I"d say."

"I candlestick speak come Professor Dumbledore and see if us can"t bend the first-year rule. Sky knows, we require a much better team than last year. Flattened in the last complement by Slytherin, ns couldn"t look Severus Snape in the confront for weeks...." < this to be Prof. McGonagall speaking - DVK >


*

When McGonagall was informing Wood about Harry (or somewhere really close come that), she claimed she"d speak to Dumbledore about getting an exemption for him.

"He"s simply the construct for a Seeker, too," claimed Wood, now walking approximately Harry and also staring in ~ him. "Light -- speedy -- we"ll have to gain him a kind broom, Professor -- a Nimbus two Thousand or a Cleansweep Seven, I"d say."

"I candlestick speak to Professor Dumbledore and also see if we can"t bending the first-year rule. sky knows, we require a much better team than last year. Flattened in the last enhance by Slytherin, i couldn"t watch Severus Snape in the face for weeks..."


*

I think the exemption was to join the team, and I think it is implied the the broomstick is for Quidditch only, and not because that use external these times. The course, the would have needed to practice on his own at times.

IIRC, this is not explicitly stated, however, ns think that Harry utilizing it for his very own purposes would have been thought about breaching the rules.

Yes, McGonagall did break the rules by getting Harry into the team, yet had this agreed. Part of this would seem to be him getting a broom to use.


The rule says that first years are indeed not allowed to carry their very own broomsticks, but I think in Harry"s instance this ascendancy is bent since he was the very first first year college student in a century come play quidditch. Possibly the "no broom" dominion is for an initial year students because they"re not selected because that the quidditch team till the second year at hogwart (as additionally mentioned by Ron).Hope the made sense? O.o


The rule is most likely implemented because first years cannot control brooms, whereby as harry was exceptionally competent, therefor enabling an exemption because that the rule.


Thanks for contributing an answer to scientific research Fiction & Fantasy ridge Exchange!

Please be sure to answer the question. Administer details and also share your research!

But avoid

Asking for help, clarification, or responding to various other answers.Making statements based upon opinion; ago them increase with references or an individual experience.

See more: When Does Nico Robin Join The Crew, Episode 130

To learn more, check out our advice on writing great answers.


write-up Your prize Discard

By clicking “Post your Answer”, friend agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy


Not the prize you're spring for? Browse other questions tagged harry-potter or questioning your own question.


does it rest a dominion for a very first year to play Quidditch because that his/her home team, or is it just tradition?
site architecture / logo design © 2021 ridge Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. Rev2021.9.24.40305


her privacy

By clicking “Accept every cookies”, friend agree stack Exchange can store cookie on your machine and disclose information in accordance through our Cookie Policy.